StATS: Surrogate outcomes (March 23, 2005, Evidence, Clinical Importance)
I'm on the mailing list of the Alliance for Human Research Protection, and they highlighted a book review:
- Is Evidence-Based Medicine Evidence Based? Bodenheimer T. Health Affairs 2005: 24(2); 562-563.
for the book
- Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine. John Abramson (2004), HarperCollins [BookFinder4U link]
Other reviews of this book appears on the Blogcritics.org, about.com, and medicalconsumers.org websites:
and in JAMA
- Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine. Detsky AS. JAMA 2005: 293(10); 1271.
The author has his own website:
I have not read this book yet, but I did read several reviews. The thing that caught my eye about the review in Health Affairs was the description of a drug, Fosomax (alendronate) which treats osteoporosis. Although the published literature on this drug looks quite impressive at first, it turns out that you have to treat a large number of women in order to prevent a single hip fracture. Furthermore, although Fosomax improves bone mineral density (BMD), it turns out that
BMD mainly measures the outer layer of bone (cortical bone), whereas much of the strength of bone lies in the inner structures of trabecular bone. Drugs such as Fosamax primarily strengthen cortical rather than trabecular bone, which improves the BMD score but may not contribute as much to fracture prevention.
This is a classic example of a surrogate outcome. Most patients don't care about cortical or trabecular bone density. What they care about is having to endure a broken bone or living with dowager's hump.
Surrogate outcomes (March 23, 2005, Evidence, Clinical Importance)
This page was last modified on 04/01/10. Send feedback to ssimon at cmh dot edu or click on the email link at the top of the page.
You are welcome to link to this page or other pages on this web site. Individual educational uses are also okay. Please contact me for permission to use these pages in any other way. For more details, please consult my copyright notice.
This page was written by Steve Simon while working at Children's Mercy Hospital. Although I do not hold the copyright for this material, I am reproducing it here as a service, as it is no longer available on the Children's Mercy Hospital website. Need more information? I have a page with general help resources. You can also browse for pages similar to this one at